Showing posts with label music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label music. Show all posts

Monday, August 4, 2008

The Pied Piper of Hützovina


Every documentary filmmaker has to be at least slightly in love with their subject. You don't have to subscribe to Albert Maysles' "love is all you need" approach to filmmaking, but some kind of love - ranging from universal human empathy to the kind of obsession it sometimes takes to get a film made - is pretty much a requirement.

In
The Pied Piper of Hützovina (which I watched via the excellent new on-line rental service Jaman), director Pavla Fleischer takes that to 11. The film is about Eugene Hütz, frontman of the band Gogol Bordello. He's a Ukrainian-born, New York-based punk rocker obsessed with understanding his Roma heritage and reviving Gypsy music. He's also impossibly charismatic - the kind of guy women flutter to like moths to a flame.

Fleischer is one of those moths. She meets Hütz by chance on a car ride in Eastern Europe, falls head over heels, and decides that making a film about him would be a good way to get close to him. This we learn in her somewhat rueful narration over shaky video of that fateful car ride. Young Pavla looks so in love, we just know her fall is going to be harsh.

A year later, Fleischer has gotten Hütz to agree to the film project - a road trip through Ukraine and Russia to explore his roots and meet his musical heroes. But when she and her camera crew meet up with him to start the journey, it quickly becomes clear that Hütz has his own agenda and
wants no part of her romantic plan.

To Fleischer's credit, she perseveres, and the film she ends up with isn't bad at all, if a little thin. Hütz delivers on the charisma part, jamming with Roma musicians in the Carpathian mountains, speaking seriously and emotionally about his passion for their music and culture, and arranging visits with various official keepers of the Gypsy music flame, not all of which go the way he expects. But there isn't much of an arc here; he's a guy with a guitar, on a quickie trip, with no goal and little at stake. So the story becomes as much Fleischer's as Hütz's: her disappointment, her attempts to stay connected and rescue her film. She doesn't protect herself or soft-pedal any of it, and her charm and honesty help us forgive the self-indulgence of using filmmaking as a seduction strategy.

I'm sure Fleischer learned a lot in the course of making this film: don't let your personal feelings cloud your judgment as a filmmaker; when you're directing in the field, don't dance until you're finished shooting; think through your structure and scenes before you shoot, or you'll end up having to put yourself in the film to recue it; etc.

She rescued her film pretty well. But on her next project, I bet she'll go easier on the love.

Saturday, August 2, 2008

High Tech Soul


OK, so I'm doing research. And at the moment, this involves watching a bunch of films about dance music and nightclubs. So tonight I'm watching High Tech Soul, which bills itself as "the first documentary to tackle the deep roots of techno music."

What a mess! Clip after clip after clip, no thesis, no story development, and the organizational style of a high-school class presentation. Of absolutely no interest anyone but the most committed fans. I am 25 minutes into the film and there has not yet been a music sequence used as anything more than a few seconds of b-roll. I've heard about the history of Detroit (the first nine minutes), and seen a series of brief clips about DJs, promoters, etc. I still don't know what makes techno techno, what makes it exciting, how it relates to its musical forebears, or why I should care at all.

The best film I've seen about a subgenre of popular music is Metal: A Headbanger's Journey, which addresses both fans and non-fans, doesn't take itself too seriously, and at the same time tries to answer all the common questions about the genre. In comparison, High Tech Soul is strictly amateur hour.

Monday, April 21, 2008

Life. Support. Music.

Yesterday morning I got an e-mail from a friend suggesting strongly that I go see Life. Support. Music., a film that hadn't been on my radar. She had loved Eric Daniel Metzgar's previous film, she said, which played at Hot Docs in 2006, and this new one sounded amazing.

My friend is discerning and thoughtful. But it was the description in the Hot Docs program that sealed the deal: a film about a guitarist who almost dies from a brain hemorrhage, and his family's herculean efforts to bring him back to health. So off I went.

Life. Support. Music. establishes its storytelling language right away: a bit of pre-bleed footage of Jason Crigler, and then multiple voices telling the story of the fateful night and the immediate aftermath. The voices are mostly of Jason's family - wife, parents, sister - and the four of them appear on screen at the same time, in small frames lined up in a row. This is a film made for the big screen. We understand that the four of them are going to be the ones telling the story; Jason appears in a montage of photographs, from childhood through adolescence, adulthood, marriage, and impending fatherhood. All of that is in the pre-title sequence. It's a remarkable few minutes - inventive and engrossing, establishing Jason's character visually, without anyone having to say "Jason is..."

Like The Betrayal, this is not a cinema vérité film - Metzgar clearly hasn't been a fly on the wall throughout the whole process. But he makes a virtue of necessity, using Jason's sister's diary entries to move quickly through time, and then
the family's home videos and footage shot for training purposes by the rehab hospital.

Indeed, it's the hospital video that provides the most shocking moment of the film: the first time we see Jason post-bleed, he is emaciated, limbs twisted, unable to close his mouth or move his eyes. It's hard to fathom that this is the same person we saw earlier. The rest of the film is a journey from this... to... we have no idea where it will end up.

The heart of the film is the interviews with the four family members who take care of Jason and through sheer determination slowly bring him back into consciousness. Gradually, we see him come back, start playing guitar again, and finally ease himself back into the music community that had been his professional and spiritual home before the illness. If there's ever a film that can be said to be a testament to the power of love, this is it.

The film's end credits are unusually short: Metzgar produced, directed, photographed, wrote and edited the film himself. This is not entirely unusual in the U.S. documentary-funding environment, but I've rarely seen someone perform all these roles at the same time on such a high level. I'm usually mistrustful of this kind of filmmaking. To me, one of the great things about making films is the collaborative aspect, and I think that having an outside perspective in the course of the process can often save the filmmaker from him- or herself. But in this case, there is hardly a misstep throughout. The film is visually rigorous, highly emotional and almost never goes off track or lapses into self-indulgence. There is one exception: towards the end, there is a musical montage of shots taken from various earlier scenes. Despite the strong music, the visuals have a sentimental, TV-sitcom feel.

But that's a very small quibble. This is not just a great story; it's really smart filmmaking.


Friday, April 18, 2008

Anvil! The Story of Anvil

Not all of us who toil in some part of the "arts sector" are blessed with instant success. Many of us work hard for years, watch our peers go on to international glory, and wonder if we should put away the paint brush, or the camera, or the violin, and get a "real job." The kind of job our dentist uncle might at least recognize as such, if not entirely approve of. And yet, we persevere. Sooner or later, we figure, it will turn around for us. We'll make something that will break through, that will reveal our genius to the world.

I know plenty of people for whom I doubt it will ever happen, and plenty more in between - those like me, who make an honest living in some
semi-artistic, semi-commercial enterprise. Many of us hope for more, but sometimes it's hard to keep the dream alive.

Anvil! The Story of Anvil is for all of us.

The story, in a nutshell: two guys meet in high school at the age of 14. They form a band, practically invent a whole subgenre of heavy metal, sell some records, play a few really big shows, and then fade into obscurity, watching the bands they influenced - Metallica, Megadeth, Slayer - sell millions of records and become superstars. Now, 25 years after their last successful record, it turns out they're still at it: two guys past the age of 50, working joe jobs to feed their families, and still pursuing the rock'n'roll dream. Now, they're about to make one last push for success.

Given the Flying-V guitars, the shoulder-length curly locks, the tight pants... and, oh yeah, the crushingly loud guitars and bombastic lyrics, you'd think this is going to be some kind of real-life This Is Spinal Tap. And certainly there are elements thereof. At the start of the film, guitarist Steve "Lips" Kudlow explains his job at a school-lunch catering company in a manner not unfamiliar to fans of Nigel Tufnel and David St. Hubbins. But then the story turns. Lips and his lifelong best friend, drummer Robb Reiner, reveal more of themselves. They are honest, hard-working guys who love their wives and children, and whose slightly baffled middle-class Jewish families have stuck by them. They know the door is closing
on them, if it hasn't closed already (the audience is pretty sure it closed somewhere around 1986), but they just can't bear to give up.

Do Lips and Robb get the Hollywood ending they deserve? Suffice to say the film has a Hollywood structure that befits its Hollywood director, Sacha Gervasi (who made this film because of his own Almost Famous-like history with the band). But it's still a documentary, and E.T. does not necessarily get to go home. Some people I talked to after the screening felt the film was entirely too predictable, that nothing unexpected happened. And as far as the story goes, that may be true. But I disagree: the unexpected thing is the characters - the guys are real, emotional, and completely open with the camera.

The great virtues of this film are not in the structure (which, actually, works very well, as Hollywood structure generally does). They're in the story that comes out in between the expected beats: the strains on the almost 40-year friendship, the pressures and joys of family, and Lips Kudlow's seemingly inexhaustible well of optimism and hope. How can you not root for a guy like that, even if he is a bit of a putz?

Ultimately, a good part of the reason I had a lump in my throat for much of the last third of the film is that it's a story about not giving up. There is great virtue in plugging away at what you love, and trying to get better, and just plain refusing to quit. For anyone who has a bit of Lips and Robb inside them, this is a moving, inspiring film.

P.S. Anvil! The Story of Anvil was the opening-night film at Hot Docs. More from the festival anon.

Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Compañeras

I really feel for U.S. documentary filmmakers. There is precious little funding available, broadcasters for the most part don't pre-license independent films, and filmmakers often spend far more time fundraising than making their films. I keep reading about people holding fundraisers for films, kind of like rent parties. In much of the rest of the developed world - i.e. Europe - that would be considered completely undignified. So I admire Americans for their dedication and perseverance. What I don't admire is that, too often, lack of budget is used as an excuse for bad filmmaking.

After suffering through yesterday's doc (which need not be mentioned again), I wanted to see something positive and inspiring. I also didn't have time to watch a feature-length film. So I turned once again to the PVR, and watched Compañeras, which was on PBS's Independent Lens last week. It's about Mariachi Reyna, "America's
first all-female mariachi band." (For the filmmakers' sake, I hope there aren't any angry Mexican-American grandmas out there right now who had an all-girl mariachi band in the '30s.) Certainly, the topic alone was enough to get my attention.

Unfortunately, my attention starts to waver pretty quickly. It's clear from the first five minutes that a) the filmmakers didn't have much money - there is precious little good concert footage, and b) the film was shot by someone who could never make a living as a cinematographer. The making-of story is clear: another director forced to pick up the ol' DVX100 because there's no money to hire a real shooter.

And it gets worse. What is this film about? Is it a straight profile? If so, how are the filmmakers going to sustain that for 60 minutes? Will anything actually happen in the course of the film? It's certainly not clear from the first act that it's a film where anything is supposed to happen.

Well, it turns out that, actually, a lot happens. In the course of the hour, a new member wins a tough competition for a spot in the band, and the band leader, the only gringa and the most accomplished musician in the group, is forced out. But we learn about this almost entirely through interviews, and not through
vérité scenes. Indeed, what actuality footage there is is painfully badly shot. There is no beginning, middle or end to any scene - just seemingly random shots. The fateful audition looks like it was shot by the band for its own records. There isn't a single scene that shows the women interacting and relating to each other. Structurally, there is no set-up to the story, no stakes set out at the start, no foreshadowing. No storytelling! The lack of scenes means the turning points in the story are entirely dependent on interview clips, and these interviews just don't carry the story. The filmmakers' decision to forego narration just makes things worse.

The filmmakers - co-director/shooter Matthew Buzzell and co-director/producer Elizabeth Massie - say on the Independent Lens website that they had next to no money for this film, had to shoot it between paying gigs, and thus couldn't shoot everything they wanted. OK. But is that an excuse for not having shot anything to build any actual scenes around the two central events of the film? I just don't get it.

The ladies of Mariachi Reyna deserved a better film than this. And clearly the opportunity is still out there for someone to make the great mariachi documentary.


Thursday, April 3, 2008

Young@Heart

The final film of this year's Doc Soup* season was a surefire crowd-pleaser. Young@Heart has all the elements: adorable seniors doing improbable things (performing songs by the Ramones and Coldplay, among others), lots of pop music (see above), and a natural story arc (rehearsing new songs for a performance that serves as the film’s climax). The film was made for Britain’s Channel 4, but had its North American premiere at Sundance and was picked up by Fox Searchlight – a sure sign of blockbuster expectations. But is it any good as a film?

It starts off beautifully, with a punk-rock perfomance of the Clash's "Should I Stay Or Should I Go" by a 93-year-old English fireplug named Eileen. But
it soon becomes clear that the seniors and their choir director, Bob Cilman, aren't the only characters in the movie. The film's director, Stephen Walker, inserts himself into the film with long-winded and intrusive first-person narration. We learn not just about the subjects, but that making the film has given him "24 grandparents."

Really, Stephen, who cares? We want to know about the singers, not about you. The intrusive first-person narration gives the film a TV feel - the last thing you want when watching a movie on a big screen. And Walker continues to inject himself into the film throughout. Almost never are we allowed to hear the seniors speak without first hearing his (usually awkward) off-camera question. One in situ interview with one of the singers, who is gravely ill, ends with Walker's off-camera voice wishing him a speedy recovery. As a result, a film that has all the potential to be a great cinematic experience quickly starts to feel like a cheesy British TV show, with an over-enthusiastic "presenter" always hovering just barely off-camera.

To be fair, the film has a lot of virtues. Walker never condescends to the subjects, and he mostly manages to show rather than tell. Most importantly he never asks the subjects to explain why they do what they do, but instead allows the answers to become clear in the course of the action. He recognizes what a goldmine he has - the subjects are characters in the true sense of the word: funny, self-aware, and always
honest. And for the most part he knows enough to let them carry the film.

There is one stylistic exception: the indifferently-shot vérité is sometimes interrupted by slick music videos. This happens four times in the course of the 110-minute film, and it only works half the time. The first time, a sequence in an old-folks home suddenly morphs into the group performing the Ramones' "I Wanna Be Sedated" as nursing-home residents. It's completely bizarre and
delightful. And towards the end, their performance of "Stayin' Alive," complete with geriatric strut, is too hilarious to quibble with. But the other video segments are just plopped in the middle of the film, seemingly without any rhyme or reason. It feels like they should have been DVD extras.

So, on the whole, does the film work? I would say that the director comes this close to ruining it, but somehow the characters hoist the film on their backs and pull it out of the fire. And I should
also say that my better half, Mme Holiday, and our friend D.A. disagreed with me completely. They loved the characters, and loved the film because of them. Mme Holiday said she was bothered by the intrusive narration at the beginning but soon stopped paying attention to the director's voice and just enjoyed the film. So who am I to pour cold water on that? I just think the film is a missed opportunity. It could have been so much better.

------
* The Hot Docs film festival’s year-round monthly screening series

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Classic Albums: Nirvana - Nevermind

I'm a big sucker for the Classic Albums series. I discovered it on MuchMoreMusic a while back, and was blown away. An album that I actually knew note by note - Deep Purple's Machinehead - was being deconstructed by the heavy metal gods who made it. There was bassist Roger Glover sitting at a mixing console and punching up individual tracks, showing how they got this sound and that effect. All five band members, now pushing 60 and considerably less hairy than in 1972, were telling stories about the greatest piece of work of their lives. It wasn't just rock'n'roll heaven (though the 15-year-old that's still inside me somewhere certainly felt that way), it was a really effective look inside the creative process. (OK, we're not talking Mozart here, but Deep Purple could really play, and the album is a rock'n'roll masterpiece.)

Since then I've heard that Classic Albums actually didn't do all that well in the ratings on VH-1, where it originated, because - it was felt - it was too "Inside Baseball." Turns out, rock fans actually want to know more about what goes on "Behind the Music" than about the music itself. Whatever. Once again I'm out of step with the masses.

Fortunately, the Classic Albums episodes are pretty widely available on DVD. I've picked up a few over the last couple of years, but have largely been disappointed. For some reason, the heart of the story was missing. Queen's A Night at the Opera is a good example. The
episode is driven more by the format - going through the album song by song (at least half of which aren't actually any good) - than by the story. And then of course there was the huge hole in the middle - the absence of Freddie Mercury. The bottom line was, it felt less like a documentary and more like a mass-produced TV show.

So when I picked up the episode on Nirvana's Nevermind, I wasn't terribly optimistic. Like Freddy Mercury, Kurt Cobain wasn't around to be interviewed. But something about this show really worked. The surviving band members, Dave Grohl and Krist Novoselic (looking, in a blue buttoned-down shirt, like a middle-aged accountant) speak intelligently about the time and about Cobain. Butch Vig, the producer, picks out just the right elements of the songs to focus on, and tells good stories from the studio. And the usual array of publicists, A&R people and music journalists for the most part actually add some good anecdotes and analysis.

But I think what works best about the show is this: the rise of Nirvana intercuts effectively with the song progression on the album. The songs are so personal that they allow the story to build, revealing elements of Cobain's character through their content and the way he played them. The show climaxes with Smells Like Teen Spirit, the second-last song on the album, which segues perfectly into the band's becoming an international phenomenon, and leads naturally into the wrap-up, which sums up Cobain's character and foreshadows (though never mentions) his death. All this makes it sound easy. But I bet the director and editor had to wrestle pretty hard to shape all those interviews into a story with a strong emotional climax.

Saturday, March 29, 2008

The Cult of Walt

As I was writing the last post, I started watching a doc on Bravo about Walter Ostanek, the St. Catharines-based polka band leader. It's called The Cult of Walt: Canada's Polka King, and apparently it got a Gemini nomination for best bio. Go figure.

Why do people bother to make such things? The film has no structure, no style, and worse, no soul. The narration is full of cliches such as "perfecting music that is truly timeless" (to pick one that I happened to hear as I was writing this). It rides along on Ostanek's personal charm and the obligatory bits of polka perfomance. But all it does is keep repeating how great the guy is. There's no insight, no probing questions, no attempt to universalize the story or get beneath the surface. Yawn....

Ostanek has been on my radar for years. More than ten years ago I was hired to write a proposal for a doc series with the exact same concept as the BBC's (and CBC's) "Who Do You Think You Are?" I put Walter in the proposal... and the series didn't go. (Maybe if I'd put in Don Cherry instead...) Around the same time, I saw a lovely film at an early Hot Docs, when it was still held in conference rooms at the Park Plaza hotel. It followed Ostanek and his mentor Frank Yankovic on a tour of the Canadian prairies, and it captured the soul of polka, its players and its fans -- retired farmers who would polka for five hours straight, as long as Frankie and Walter could keep playing. That film made me want to learn how to polka. Watching this newer one, I didn't even tap my toes.

Mozartballs

I got up this morning with nothing on my plate. My better half is away for the weekend, and despite a looming deadline or two I had decided to take the day off. After breakfast, instead of heading out into the sunshine, I picked a DVD from the pile next to the TV, and popped it in.

The film was Mozartballs, by one of Canada's most interesting filmmakers, Larry Weinstein.

Mozartballs was an unexpected contribution to the celebration of Mozart's 250th birthday a couple of years ago. Instead of making yet another earnest bio, Weinstein decided to focus on the fans - Mozart's wackiest, most devoted fans. A woman in Oklahoma who is convinced she's the reincarnation of Wolfgang himself, and her lesbian partner, who is apparently the reincarnation of the love of Mozart's life, one of his generation's leading sopranos. (Hurray! They found each other in this life!) A man who believes that Mozart spoke to him and saved him from suicide. A fellow who writes music "in the style of Mozart" with the help of a computer. And an Austrian cosmonaut who took Wolfgang with him into space.

The thing that most impressed me about this film was how much respect Weinstein showed his wacky subjects. There isn't a single shot in the film that suggests he's making fun of them, and yet the film is full of hilarious moments. In this respect it reminded me of of Gates of Heaven, Errol Morris's great film about a pet cemetery. But just as importantly, the film is beautifully constructed and visually rigorous. It's not just a series of profiles of wacky eccentrics; the characters have an emotional arc, both individually and collectively. By the end of the film, we get it - Mozart helps keep these people alive. May we all have something that we care about so deeply.

Finally, a note about the shooting, by one of Canada's best documentary cinematographers, John Tran. There are two shots I will remember for a long time: a shot starts on black, then pans over to some kids playing in the back yard, seen through a glass door. The shot then moves up, and reveals that the black and the reflection were both parts of a grand piano played by the Mozart-loving astronaut. The kids were seen in a barely distorted reflection in the piano. The other shot puts Ms. Mozart on a ladder, face to face with a painting of the real Mozart and his family. As she reflects on the painting - and gets quite emotional - she's seen in a reflection, framed perfectly in a triangle of black that makes her face clearly visible. John Tran rocks.

So that's number one. A pretty enjoyable beginning.

P.S. I just put in a link to the Amazon page for the film, and as I was browsing through that page, I read a review of the film by one of the subjects, who talks about why she loved the experience and the result. It's quite instructive.